
The Ultimate Question: Who Counts — and Who Decides
Clip: Season 2026 | 3m 38sVideo has Closed Captions
Freedom debated: Is it lawless, God-given, or state-protected? Who counts—and who decides?
It's the final question for BREAKING the DEADLOCK: A Matter of Life and Death. Panelists clash over freedom’s meaning and the government's role in life-and-death choices. Is freedom lawless, God-given, or state-protected? From abortion to autonomy, the debate exposes deep divides on who counts—and who decides, and the need to keep talking about these very difficult matters.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Funding for this program was provided in part by grants from The Rosalind P. Walter Foundation and by a grant from Anne Ray Foundation and by contributions from viewers like you. Thank you. Location furnished by The New York Historical.

The Ultimate Question: Who Counts — and Who Decides
Clip: Season 2026 | 3m 38sVideo has Closed Captions
It's the final question for BREAKING the DEADLOCK: A Matter of Life and Death. Panelists clash over freedom’s meaning and the government's role in life-and-death choices. Is freedom lawless, God-given, or state-protected? From abortion to autonomy, the debate exposes deep divides on who counts—and who decides, and the need to keep talking about these very difficult matters.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Breaking the Deadlock
Breaking the Deadlock is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- How should we think about freedom and the role of our government and the hard life and death choices we all face?
- We need to start thinking about it.
And we can't think that the government is gonna give us the answers.
These are questions that are happening around kitchen tables, around school cafeterias, in classrooms, in doctor's offices.
We need to start figuring out that this is something that all of us care about.
- Some of us have been thinking about it our whole lives because our people have never had it.
Those people can be Indigenous, Black, women, trans folks, children (chuckles), who often aren't even counted in these conversations.
Some of us have been thinking about freedom forever.
And what we have been convinced of, unfortunately, is that this country seems to be determined to answer us in the negative.
And so, yes, we need to decide if we're going to take freedom seriously.
And I'm hoping that some people catch up to recognizing that the answer being yes means letting go of the attempts to try to control other people.
(people clapping) - Well, my views are, A, we're gonna have some disagreements about the nature of freedom, who grants it to us, who gives us our rights?
Some people will always believe that our rights are derived from government.
I happen to believe our rights are derived from God.
And I think when you have a faith system that teaches you where your rights come from or what immutable traits or immutable truths are, you're inevitably gonna have some disagreements with your fellow citizens.
Why are we free?
And it's not because government or a piece of paper told us we are, it's because we're all God's children, that's my personal view.
- It's really interesting to have these conversations about freedom because in Canada, there is no abortion law.
It is not legal.
It is not illegal.
And it turns out, that works just fine, that the abortion rate is not higher.
It turns out that not having a law works great.
Isn't that the definition of freedom, not having a law?
- Well, it comes down to who counts.
Who counts under our laws?
When we think about something like abortion, my contention is that life is precious and the circumstances, which may be horrible in some cases, we have to have compassion and help those in those difficult situations.
But we don't create more victims.
And it starts by recognizing that every human person deserves that shot at life.
- Look, I think difficult decisions, many of 'em we've had these heart-wrenching decisions, shouldn't be made by the government.
Should be made by the woman in consultation with her family, her faith, if she so chooses.
My freedom and your freedom may be different.
I don't think it's government that grants it, but I think the government has to protect it.
When Pregnancy Turns Perilous: Inside the Toughest Pregnancy Decisions
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S2026 | 4m 30s | A personal story ignites a vital debate: when pregnancy turns perilous, who gets to decide? (4m 30s)
The Ultimate Question: Who Counts — and Who Decides
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S2026 | 3m 38s | Freedom debated: Is it lawless, God-given, or state-protected? Who counts—and who decides? (3m 38s)
Should You Help End a Life? A Father’s Final Request
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S2026 | 5m 45s | A father wants control over his death. His sons must decide: help him, or stop him? (5m 45s)
A Matter of Life and Death: Preview
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S2026 | 30s | Watch the preview for BREAKING THE DEADLOCK: A MATTER OF LIFE AND DEATH (30s)
A Matter of Life and Death: Episode Open
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S2026 | 1m 5s | Watch the open for BREAKING THE DEADLOCK: A MATTER OF LIFE AND DEATH. (1m 5s)
Law vs. Life: The Abortion Debate Gets Personal
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S2026 | 4m 12s | A rare pregnancy crisis sparks debate on law, life, and choice—plus one panelist’s real ordeal. (4m 12s)
Abortion Pills at Home: Privacy vs. Parental Rights
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S2026 | 5m 36s | Parents find abortion pills in their teen’s room. Watch the clip to see the debate that ensues! (5m 36s)
Abortion Across State Lines: A Parent’s Dilemma
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S2026 | 3m 51s | Would you break the law to help your teen’s pregnant friend get an abortion? (3m 51s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

FRONTLINE is investigative journalism that questions, explains and changes our world.












Support for PBS provided by:
Funding for this program was provided in part by grants from The Rosalind P. Walter Foundation and by a grant from Anne Ray Foundation and by contributions from viewers like you. Thank you. Location furnished by The New York Historical.







